Timing, Transitions, and Careers

Added by the EDUCAUSE Librarian

© 2006 Carole A. Barone

EDUCAUSE Review, vol. 41, no. 5 (September/October 2006): 144

Timing, Transitions, and Careers

Carole A. Barone
Carole A. Barone, Senior Fellow, is retiring from EDUCAUSE at the end of this year. Previously, she was responsible for the EDUCAUSE teaching and learning efforts, particularly the National Learning Infrastructure Initiative (NLII). Before coming to EDUCAUSE, she was Associate Vice Chancellor for Information Technology at the University of California, Davis, and Vice President for Information Systems and Computing at Syracuse University. Barone received the 1995 CAUSE ELITE Award for Exemplary Leadership and Information Technology Excellence. Comments on this article can be sent to the author at cbarone@educause.edu.

Timing, in the abstract, does not carry high priority on the list of issues and challenges facing IT professionals on a daily basis. However, whenever the time comes, for whatever it is that the time has come, timing suddenly becomes paramount.

Timing is relative, largely determined by culture, by convictions, and indeed by time itself. Time, timing, tempo, trajectory, transition, transformation—such words often conjure up feelings of testiness, temptation, tension, even terror. It is time to reflect on our notions of timing—and the interplay with transitions and careers.

Patience and pacing are critical aspects of timing. Early in a career, having the good sense and patience to endure in dues-paying mode allows the young IT professional to learn from the experience of making mistakes at the appropriate level. Being impatient to advance sometimes has the unanticipated consequence of positioning the inexperienced professional to blunder into mistakes that should have been made at a lower level. Time in place also allows one to lead from where one is, irrespective of the formal organization chart. Acquiring the ability to quickly and astutely identify opportunities for facilitating systemic change can begin early in a career. Leading from where you are also affords occasions for ones potential to be noticed and noted. Taking responsibility for grooming, and positioning, oneself to succeed later in strategic IT leadership roles is an early expression of professional identity.

By midcareer, we have established an identity around the work we do. Perhaps because of this internalization of our work, we sometimes need to be jolted into recognizing that it is time to examine, or reexamine, our convictions. For example, IT professionals are being called on now to be partners in addressing campus issues, not just campus IT issues. . . . Our profession has evolved and our experience has deepened. It is time to engage in higher educations grand challenges.1 The mandate to break out of the technology cocoon portends a new reality for IT professionals. This is a time to seek guidance and good counsel through ones professional associations.

Balance is a dimension of timing that applies to all phases of a career. Play helps to preserve balance by refreshing our perspective, so that we are able to recognize opportunities and to visualize new futures. As we progress through our careers, pressures build and time becomes scarce. For some of us, play is a learned skill. We have to work at developing and maintaining the ability to play. It is a professional mistake to use time constraints as an excuse for not gaining and retaining the ability to play.

Then, just as we are beginning to enjoy the benefits of balance and to savor the delicious fruits of experience, the time comes to contemplate retirement. Experience diminishes fear and reveals the unanticipated enrichment conferred by embracing or lurching into the previously unknown. Retirement forces one to learn a new art—that of letting go. We have a professional responsibility to make way for the next generation. To do so gracefully means again changing the balance of ones life, this time shifting the focus from work and becoming more emotionally and intellectually engaged with ones family and community—while also continuing to play.

Thus, I end on a personal note. The Hawaiian phrase pau hana celebrates the transition from work to play. It is a value statement that connotes the importance of the time after work. Now is the time for me to celebrate pau hana. My work is finished.

Note

1. A Message from the EDUCAUSE Executive Team, EDUCAUSE Review, vol. 41, no. 3 (May/June 2006): 4, http://www.educause.edu/er/erm06/erm06312.asp.

Submitted by Gary Brown (Washington State University) on Sun, 2006/11/05 - 8:20pm.
Carole,

I recall our first meeting in Florida shortly after I had grabbed onto the life raft of insights in your writing, particularly your observation about the shortcomings of “boutique” solutions for integrating technology. (Of course I was in a role presumed to be responsible for supporting those lovely little desert orchids.)

Your insights in person were equally or even more useful and penetrating. I enjoyed working with you, however briefly, in our toe-dip work into “The New Academy” and “Transformative Assessment” where we discovered how profoundly busy everybody doing this work has become. Pau hana!

Now as you move away from this work, I know you will be busy, still, in other important ways, but I am better, wiser, and deeply grateful for your leadership and your courage and your eloquence as one of the first to see clearly the limits of our traditional academic culture and to call for our whole community to do more to work together if our work is to remain relevant at all.

Sincerely,
Gary Brown
Submitted by Ulrich Rauch (The University of British Columbia) on Fri, 2006/11/03 - 2:06pm.
What would Carole do? … I often reflect on that when working with senior University administrators who want to remain convinced that teaching (and by extension learning) are in the final analysis, highly solipsistic and isolating experiences. It is at those times that I admire the courage Carole has shown in pursuing her vision and her understanding of the new learning environment we are inhabiting .... as we are shaping it collectively. And look where we are today …. would anyone have believed that the American Federation of Scientist should declare that video games may redefine education? Without educators like Carole promoting a total openness to redefining our perceptions of learning and pedagogy, without her grasp of the technologies, in place already or yet to be conceptualized, without her willingness (and sometime pleasure) to subvert obsolete academic practice, I would not have learned how to reconcile academic work and technical proficiency. Carole, you continue to be my inspiration, a radical thinker and visionary, a wonderful mentor … thank you for all you have given us … this is our time to celebrate you!
Submitted by Patricia A. McGee (University of Texas at San Antonio) on Tue, 2006/10/31 - 3:24pm.
You may not know it, but Carole, you and Vicki Suter have done more to influence my professional understanding, sensibility, and knowledge (through the NLII fellowship and subsequent support and encouragement) than any other single experience or individual. Were you aware of this? Probably not, but you should be. I have valued just about everything you have written or that I have heard you say (dinners may be a bit foggy) but most importantly I value the connectedness you have fostered with brilliant people that has resulted in a vigorous and dedicated community of practice. We carry on your work, in small and humble pieces. I for one, when presented with a particularly confounding dilemma will pause and ponder, “what would Carole do?” You rock!
Submitted by carmean on Tue, 2006/10/31 - 12:02am.
Dearest Carole:
May your transition to play be glorious! How well you deserve it after years of thoughtful leadership and NLII's always dynamic list of pressing issues for higher education: IMS & SCORM, faculty engagement, ePortfolios, deeper learning, the future CMS, learning objects, open source...my head still hurts remembering how hard NLII Fellows would work. The opportunity was great, ideas were so important and your mentoring such a rare opportunity to learn and become. Who needed sleep?

You taught many of us to be brave and outspoken for a worthy cause, for the fate of the generation still behind us is worth the fight. Your work is not done. It carries on in each change agent you created. Pau hana!

Colleen Carmean
National Learning Infrastructure Initiative Fellow 2002
EDUCAUSE Logo

EDUCAUSE and EDUCAUSE Review are registered trademarks. Materials may be photocopied for noncommercial use without written permission provided appropriate credit is given to both EDUCAUSE Review and the author(s). Permission to republish must be sought in writing (contact editor@educause.edu). Statements of fact or opinion are made on the responsibility of the authors alone and do not imply an opinion on the part of the EDUCAUSE Board of Directors, staff, or members. For more information about copyright, see www.educause.edu/copyright.